Weight loss shakes do work, a little. Swap a meal or two a day for a shake and you eat fewer kilojoules without having to count them, and the research shows that helps. But the difference over a year is smaller than the labels suggest, and it depends on what you eat the rest of the day. Most people want to lose the winter coat at some point. Here’s what the evidence says, and which shakes are worth buying in Australia.
- Best for most men: The Man Shake. About A$3.70 a serve, 30 g protein, around 209 calories. Sold in Coles, Woolworths and online.
- Best for a structured low-calorie plan: The Fast 800 shakes. About 200 calories and 20 g protein, built around the Fast 800 diet.
- Not a meal replacement: Musashi Shred & Burn is a protein powder with caffeine. Good after training, not instead of lunch.
- Lots to lose, or a medical reason: very-low-calorie programs like Optifast, but only with your GP.
Do weight loss shakes work?
The best evidence is a 2019 review in Obesity Reviews that pooled 23 trials and 7,884 adults. People whose diet included meal replacement shakes lost about 1.4 kg more after a year than people on other diets. With regular coaching, the gap grew to about 6 kg. The authors concluded shakes “should be considered as a valid option”.
Australia’s Healthy Male reaches the same conclusion: low-calorie diets built on shakes beat food-based ones. It also points out that very few of the trials were done on men, and that shakes aren’t meant for long-term use. Australia’s NHMRC advises using them with help from a health professional.
So shakes help, mainly because they make portions automatic. They don’t burn fat on their own, whatever the tub says. What matters is the kilojoules you eat across the day.

The best weight loss shakes for men in Australia
| Shake | Price | Per serve | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Man Shake | A$54.95 for 15 serves | 209 cal, 30 g protein, 2.4 g sugar | Swapping one or two meals a day |
| The Fast 800 Original | A$49.99 | 202 cal, 20.4 g protein | Following the Fast 800 plan |
| Musashi Shred & Burn | A$78.99 for 900 g | 22 g protein, 99 mg caffeine | After training (not a meal) |
| Optifast VLCD | Pharmacies | Under 800 cal a day on the full program | Medically supervised weight loss |
The Man Shake
An Australian shake made for men, and the one most blokes will have seen in the supermarket. A serve is two scoops in water: about 209 calories and 30 g of whey protein (Nutrition Warehouse), with 7.5 g of fibre and 2.4 g of sugar (The Man Shake). A tub has 15 serves for A$54.95, so about A$3.70 a shake. The plan is two shakes, two snacks and one normal meal a day.
The protein is the strong point: 30 g keeps you fuller than most shakes and helps you hold on to muscle while you lose weight. The brand also says it contains a “natural fat burner formulation”. We haven’t found a trial of the shake itself showing that does anything extra.

The Fast 800 shakes
These come from the Fast 800 diet created by the late Dr Michael Mosley. The Original shake is 202 calories with 20.4 g of protein and costs A$49.99 (The Fast 800). They’re designed to fit an 800-calorie day in the plan’s strict phase. Less protein than The Man Shake, but a good fit if you’re following the full program.
Musashi Shred & Burn
Often sold as a weight loss shake, but it’s really a protein powder: 22 g protein per serve plus carnitine, choline and 99 mg of caffeine (Musashi). It’s batch-tested by Informed Sport, which matters if you compete. Use it after training, not instead of a meal, and skip it late in the day.

Optifast and other very-low-calorie diets
Optifast-style programs replace every meal and keep you under about 800 calories (3,300 kJ) a day, which is what Healthy Male calls a very low energy diet. They can take weight off fast, but they’re a different tool from the shakes above. Talk to your GP before starting one.
How to use weight loss shakes
- Replace one or two meals, not all of them. Breakfast and lunch are the easy swaps. Eat a proper dinner with vegetables and protein.
- Look for 20 g of protein or more and low sugar. Protein keeps you full; sugar does the opposite.
- Mix with water unless you’ve counted the milk. Milk adds calories to every shake.
- Keep training. Weights while you diet help make sure what you lose is fat, not muscle.
- Plan the exit. Shakes are a start. Use the weeks on them to work out the meals you’ll eat when you stop.
FAQ
Does The Man Shake work?
It works the way any meal replacement does: by replacing a bigger meal with a 209-calorie one. With 30 g of protein it’s more filling than most. The research on shakes in general (Astbury et al., 2019) shows modest extra weight loss over a year, more with coaching.
How much weight can you lose with shakes?
In the 2019 review, about 1.4 kg more over a year than other diets, and about 6 kg more with regular support (Obesity Reviews). How much you lose in total depends on your whole diet.
Are weight loss shakes safe?
For most healthy adults, replacing one or two meals is fine. Very-low-calorie programs that replace every meal should be done with a doctor, and Healthy Male notes shakes aren’t meant for long-term use.
Is a protein shake the same as a meal replacement?
No. A meal replacement adds carbs, fibre, vitamins and minerals so it can stand in for a meal. A protein shake like Musashi Shred & Burn is mostly protein and is meant to go alongside meals.
Can you just drink shakes and not eat?
Not without medical supervision. Programs that replace every meal are very low calorie and need a GP’s oversight.
This article is general information, not medical advice. Some links are affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, Men’s Fitness Online earns from qualifying purchases, and we may earn a commission from other retailers at no extra cost to you.









